More flavor for less

Italian for

Everyone

Goodfellas on Staten Island is an award winning establishment.

2007, 2009 & 2012 “World’s Best Pizza” and 2010 “Best Pizza on the East Coast”.

Simply Delicious

The taste you’ll remember.

Delicious pizzas and pastas

Our entire staff would to welcome you, your family and your friends to Goodfella’s.

Specializing in creating unique and personalized experiences, we serve only the best Italian pizzas, pastas and appetizers.

Taste the Mediterranean culture

We offer delivery, take out, catering and private parties.

A big part of the Goodfella’s experience is the friendly service and wide selection of mouthwatering food.

Buon Appetito!

Our Happy Customers

TESTIMONIALS

This is the best pizza on Staten Island 1000%. Their Pizza alla Vodka is absolutely incredible and is definitely the highlight here. I just wish I lived closer so I could get it all the time. Highly recommend this Italian restaurant if you're looking for authentic Italian - @travellingappetite

Lisa Mifsud

Absolutely amazing Italian restaurant. We stumbled across this place when visiting Staten Island from New York and I'm so glad we did. The pizzas and trays are so affordable and great value for money - @hungryexplorer___

Lauren Brown

Goodfella's is an excellent Italian restaurant and voted Bloc's best pizza on Staten Island recently. The pies are great value and cooked to perfection every time. Great venue, setting the standard of how pizzas should be made in NY - Joshua Wood, CEO of Bloc.