
There are few things in life that are perfect. But one thing everyone can agree on is that pizza comes pretty darn close. When talking about the best pizza takeout in Staten Island, there’s no doubt that Goodfellas Pizza is always at the top of the list.
Discover the secret behind Goodfellas Pizza’s greatness. Our crust is simply unmatched – not too thick, not too thin, but perfectly crispy. And what sets them apart is our secret blend of herbs and spices, infusing each bite with a one-of-a-kind, irresistible flavour.
Discover the essential element – the toppings! Goodfellas Pizza presents an extensive selection of fresh toppings, encompassing beloved classics such as pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions. Not only that, we boast exceptional choices like prosciutto, artichoke hearts, and even roasted garlic. Unleash your creativity and craft your perfect pizza masterpiece with our array of mouthwatering options.
Goodfellas Pizza – The Only Choice for Pizza Lovers in Staten Island
A Slice of History
Goodfellas Pizza has been serving up mouth-watering pizzas in Staten Island for years. With over many years of experience, we have perfected the art of making the perfect pizza.
Quality Ingredients = Delicious Pizzas
Experience the difference at Goodfellas Pizza with our superior ingredients. We take pride in choosing only the finest vegetables and premium meats, ensuring each bite is a taste sensation.
The Perfect Crust
As mentioned before, Goodfellas Pizza’s crust is simply unbeatable. It’s not too thick, not too thin, and has just the right amount of chewiness. And let’s not forget about that irresistible crunch!
A Pizza for Every Taste

No matter what kind of pizza lover you are, Goodfellas Pizza has got you covered. From traditional options like Pizza Alla Vodka and Eggplant Parmigiana to unique creations like Chicken Marsala and Chicken Francese, there is something for everyone on our menu.
Not Just Pizza
At Goodfellas Pizza, we go beyond just pizza. Discover our delectable selection of whole wheat wraps, pasta dishes, and salads alongside our famous pizzas. Feast on an array of mouth-watering options at our pizzeria.
Convenient Takeout Options
In today’s fast-paced world, sometimes we just don’t have time to sit down and enjoy a meal at a restaurant. That’s where Goodfellas Pizza’s takeout option comes in handy. You can easily place your order online or over the phone and pick it up at your convenience.
So next time you find yourself craving pizza, skip the mediocre options and head straight to Goodfellas Pizza for the best pizza takeout experience in all of Staten Island. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you. So why wait? Place your order now and experience the goodness of Goodfellas Pizza for yourself!
Supporting Local Businesses
Indulge in a delectable meal while supporting a local Staten Island gem – Goodfellas Pizza. Our family-run pizzeria takes immense pride in our food and community. Every dollar spent here helps our neighborhood thrive and fosters a stronger sense of community. Treat yourself and give back, all in one delicious bite.
Bringing People Together
There’s nothing quite like sharing a piping hot pizza with friends and family. Goodfellas Pizza knows this and offers catering services for parties and events. Our delicious pizzas are sure to bring a smile to everyone’s face and make any gathering a memorable one.
Conclusion
Goodfellas Pizza truly lives up to its name – it’s the pizza joint that will have you feeling like you’re in the “family”. With our commitment to quality ingredients, unbeatable crust, and variety of options, it’s no wonder we are considered the best pizza takeout in all of Staten Island. So next time you’re craving a slice, make sure to choose Goodfellas Pizza – your taste buds will thank you! So come on down and join the “Goodfellas” family today. Until then, happy eating, friends!