
The aroma of freshly-baked pizza, the sizzling sounds of the grill, the clinking of glasses filled with cold beer – these are just some of the sensory sensations one can experience when dining at Goodfella’s on Staten Island.
This casual, family-friendly joint has been serving up delicious and authentic Italian cuisine for over 25 years. If you’re a foodie or just someone who loves a good meal, then you need to check out what Goodfella’s has to offer.
The Pizza
Let’s start with the obvious – the pizza. Goodfella’s has been voted “Best Pizza on Staten Island” multiple times, and for good reason. Our traditional thin-crust pies are made with only the freshest ingredients, including homemade mozzarella cheese and San Marzano tomatoes imported from Italy.
But don’t just take my word for it – try our famous sally pie, topped with lemon garlic chicken with roasted rosemary potatoes & an incredible combination of fresh mozzarella, cheddar, mushrooms, caramelized onions, topped with a gourmet cheddar scallion cream sauce. It’s a flavor explosion in your mouth.
The Menu
If you’re not in the mood for pizza, fear not because the menu at Goodfella’s has much more to offer. Our pasta dishes are homemade and the sauces are rich, hearty, and full of flavor.

One standout dish is the rigatoni ala vodka – perfectly cooked rigatoni pasta smothered in a creamy. It’s decadent, delicious, and just the right amount of spicy. And, for all those carb-lovers out there, we even offer “Gnocchi Pomodoro”.
The Street Food
Alright, now let’s talk about something a little different: street food. Goodfella’s knows how to do it right with a whole section of our menu dedicated to these tasty bites. It’s perfect for sharing or if you just want a light meal. One dish you absolutely have to try is our buffalo chicken “wings”.
Picture bite-sized pieces of chicken, marinated in delicious buffalo sauce and served with a side of creamy blue cheese dressing. We’re crispy, juicy, and so darn tasty. But wait, there’s more! Don’t forget about the fries. Whether you like them sweet or savory, Goodfella’s has got you covered. So get ready to feast on some seriously good street food.
The Drinks
Hold up, there’s even more to get excited about! Goodfella’s not only serves up delicious food, but we’ve also got a kick-ass bar stocked with a wide range of beers and wines.
We’ve got everything from local brews to international favorites, catering to all taste buds out there. And guess what? The bar area is the ultimate hangout spot to catch a game or chill with your buddies over a few tipples. It’s a win-win situation, my friend!
The Atmosphere
You won’t find a friendlier joint than Goodfella’s! This place is all about family vibes and tasty treats. The staff are like superheroes, making sure you’re comfy and full to the brim.
Oh, and don’t forget to bring the little rugrats, because we’ll go crazy for the homemade pizzas and amazing atmosphere. And if you fancy a chinwag with your mates, grab a brewski from Goodfella’s epic range of local and imported beers. Cheers to that!
Conclusion:
If you’re craving some mind-blowing Staten Island grub, then you gotta get yourself to Goodfella’s. Our menu is jam-packed with deliciousness, our ingredients are as fresh as it gets, and our dishes will have your taste buds doing a happy dance.
Plus, the vibes are totally chill and relaxed, making it the ultimate spot for a killer family feast or a wild night out with your buddies. Trust me, you won’t leave Goodfella’s without a big ol’ smile on your face. So, bring your appetite, get ready to indulge, and prepare to be blown away by everything that Goodfella’s serves up.