
Are you craving for a slice of pizza right now? Good news, you don’t have to look very far because Goodfellas in Staten Island has got your back. Located in the heart of the city, Goodfellas has been a go-to destination for pizza enthusiasts in Staten Island and beyond.
From authentic New York-style pizza to creative toppings that will satisfy your tastebuds, Goodfellas has it all. In this blog, we’ll dive deeper into why Goodfellas is worth a visit and the top reasons why it ranks among the top pizza restaurants in Staten Island.
Authentic New York-style pizza
What’s a more classic pizza style than the New York-style? Goodfellas masterfully captures the essence of this iconic pizza style by using fresh ingredients, the right techniques, and the pride of the city’s culinary tradition.
You know what makes a killer New York-style pizza? It’s all in the crust, baby! Picture this: a thin, crispy outer layer that gives way to a delightfully chewy center. And let’s not forget about the cheese – it’s perfectly gooey, just the way it should be. And the tomato sauce? It’s a sweet and tangy symphony of flavor, hitting all the right notes. One bite of this slice and you’ll know this is the real deal. This is pizza perfection, my friends.
Creative toppings

If you’re feeling like trying something new, Goodfellas has an impressive selection of toppings that will compliment your pizza without overpowering it.
You can choose from more classic variations like pepperoni and mushrooms to more unusual ones like buffalo chicken, bacon mac and cheese, or grandma pie – which encompasses fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, bread crumbs, and basil, topped with dollops of San Marzano sauce.
Family-friendly atmosphere
Goodfellas is the perfect hangout spot for both families and large groups. The restaurant’s atmosphere is laid back, yet lively, and the staff pays attention to every customer’s needs. The seating area is spacious and accommodates both intimate and large groups, and the noise level is moderate, making it easy to have a conversation over a meal.
Catering options
Throwing a bash? Goodfellas has got your back! We’ll handle the food, so you can focus on the fun. Our catering options are perfect for birthdays, corporate gigs, or any other shindig. And guess what? We’re not just cookie-cutter caterers. Our menu will be tailored to your tastes, and our service will blow your guests away. Don’t take our word for it, check out our website or ring us up to find out more about our amazing catering packages. Your taste buds will thank you!
Affordable prices
Who says quality pizza has to cost a fortune? Goodfellas offers delicious pies at reasonable prices, making it an affordable option for those on a budget. You can enjoy your favorite flavors without breaking the bank. Plus, we have special discounts and deals that you can take advantage of – so keep an eye out on our website or social media pages.
The Ambiance
You’ve gotta try Goodfellas! Their pizza is out of this world. And let’s talk about the vibe – it’s like cozy luxury meets chill vibes. Whether you’re with the fam or your squad, the place is guaranteed to give you a chill and unforgettable time.
Conclusion:
So here’s the deal – if you want the absolute best pizza in town, you gotta check out Goodfellas in Staten Island. I’m talking about authentic New York-style pizza with toppings that will blow your mind. Plus, it’s the perfect place to bring the fam or cater your next big event. And the best part? It won’t break the bank. Don’t waste another second – get yourself to Goodfellas and experience pizza nirvana like never before. Trust me, you won’t regret it.