
The history of restaurants on Staten Island is one of the most engrossing stories in the culinary world. The area has long been known for its diverse food scene, with influences from all around the world. From Italian-American to Chinese and Greek cuisine, there are numberless styles of food that call Staten Island home.
As a result, it’s no surprise that it has become a hot spot for restaurants and eateries in recent years. In this article, we’ll explore the evolution of restaurants on Staten Island, from its before time days to its present status as one of New York City’s premier dining destinations.
We’ll take a look at some of the oldest establishments still operating, delve into the influence of international cuisines, and tour some of the most popular hot spots today. Whether you’re a foodie or just strange about the history of this vibrant borough, this overview is sure to satisfy your curiosity. So let’s get started!
When you think of Staten Island, what’s the first thing that comes to mind? For most people, it’s probably pizza or Italian food. But did you know that the history of restaurants on Staten Island actually dates back centuries? Let’s take a bite into this delicious tale and explore how far back this borough’s food culture goes.
From Taverns to Hotels
The earliest restaurants in Staten Island were taverns, which served as a place for passenger to get a warm meal and a place to sleep. One of the oldest known taverns was The Sign of The Spread Eagle, which opened in 1774 in Richmondtown. It was owned by Colonel Christopher Billop and was popular with locals and travelers alike. In fact, George Washington himself visited the tavern several times during his tenure as president!
Seafood Shacks Galore
Back in the late 1800s and early 1900s, seafood shacks dotted the island’s coastline. These shacks were simple establishments where fishermen could sell their fresh catches directly to customers who came from all over New York City looking for something new and unique.
Many of these seafood shacks still exist today, though they now serve more than just fish – everything from tacos to burgers can be found at many local spots.
Italian Eats Everywhere

It would be wrong to talk about restaurants on Staten Island without mentioning Italian cuisine – after all, there are more Italian-Americans living here than anywhere else in America! The roots of Italian cuisine on Staten Island go back centuries; immigrants from Sicily began arriving here in large numbers during the late 1800s, bringing with them recipes passed down generation after generation. Today, almost every neighborhood has a few Italian restaurants serving up mouthwatering dishes like lasagna and cannoli.
Goodfella’s restaurants on Staten Island, NY have been winning the hearts of customers since opening. This one-of-a-kind dining experience is a review favorite due to its delicious wood fired pizza, flatbread, and brick oven favorites like our famous Goodfella’s Baked Clams. The restaurant has become known for incorporating fresh New York ingredients and flavors into traditional Italian cooking that makes mouths water.
Whether looking for a unique event space or simply some fantastic food, Goodfella’s restaurants are the perfect spot for any occasion. Customers rave about the restaurants’ ambience and attentive staff, creating an amazing overall atmosphere that leaves visitors feeling satisfied from start to finish.
Conclusion
From taverns dating back to colonial times to modern-day seafood shacks and Italian eateries galore, it’s clear that restaurants have been an integral part of life on Staten Island for centuries.
Whether you have lived here your whole life or are planning a visit soon, make sure you take some time out of your day to sample the delicious fare available around town – you won’t regret it! No matter what type of food you’re craving – whether it’s pizza or something more exotic – there’s sure to be something out there for everyone on this amazing island. Bon Appétit!